Ubuntu Forums Archive Viewer

Should I format to ext2 on Windows XP

Archived thread 1011203 from Other OS Talk. Markdown source: Other_OS_Talk/thread_1011203_Should_I_format_to_ext2_on_Windows_XP.md

Original URL About this archive
#1

I'm tired of having to constantly defrag my windows partitions to get games to run with freezing. I read that you can reformat a partition to ext2 on windows.

How well does this work? Is it generally faster than NTFS? Has anyone here tried it?

#2

No, I think thats not possible. The ext2 driver aims at sharing files, like the ntfs read/write functionality in Linux.

#3

It's not possible to install windows on anything but FAT&NTFS formatted partitions. You heard wrong.

#4

mips said: It's not possible to install windows on anything but FAT&NTFS formatted partitions. You heard wrong.

I'm not trying to install windows.

I have windows on Drive C and a games partition on Drive D. I want to reformat Drive D to ext2.

#5

Ext2 is the "old default" filesystem for Linux. The successor of Ext2 is Ext3, which is a journaling filesystem (that can sometimes make a huge difference when using it in other Operating Systems.)

In MS-Windows there are a few options to read/write to Ext2 or Ext3 partitions, but i'm not sure that there's a transparent solution to be used for gaming in Windows.

But take a look at this : http://www.howtoforge.com/access-linux-partitions-from-windows and see for yourself.

#6

dont do it if its a dedicated windows partition, since windows wont be able to fsck the partition in the event of a dirty shutdown...

if you plan to share the partition with a linux install, then i would definately consider it.

#7

u-slayer said: I'm not trying to install windows.

I have windows on Drive C and a games partition on Drive D. I want to reformat Drive D to ext2.

In that case it can be done but I find it slower than ntfs. There are also issues if something should go wrong like not unmounting the filesystem properly etc.

#8

The best filesystem for Windows is NTFS - sorry...

#9

hermanab said: the best filesystem for windows is ntfs - sorry...

+1