kayosiii said: ok well firstly filters have a place in photography even with digital maniplation if you manage to clip a colour channel then there is very little to get that back.
Beyond that though you might want to give the following a shot... 1) Colours->Invert 2) Colours->Components->Decompose->CMY you should now have greyscale layers roughly corresponding to Cyan Magenta and Yellow from the original image. 3) Set the layer mode of Cyan and Magenta Channels to overlay (I am not 100% sure this is correct - play with other layer modes as well to see what you get) 4) now you can use the layer opacity slider on the cyan and magenta layers to drop their relative contribution to the image. which is essentially what the yellow filter does.
wow, that really helped. it didn't work exactly how you described, but it was a great pointer for how I wanted my black and whites to look like. for those who might want to do something similar:
I grabbed a picture from flickr (I'm on my eee pc, my pics aren't here).
2a. note: bc colors were inverted, what you see as yellow is in fact blue
- invert colors
- decompose to cmy
- put cyan layer on top, magenta below that, yellow at the bottom (the one with the most contrast goes to the top, the least goes to the bottom)
- turn yellow layer invisible (unnecessary but just in case it has an effect)
- play around with cyan and magenta to taste.
- save as jpg, done
here are the result (file name is: blue-CMY.jpg), along with the original (blue.jpg) and a desaturated copy of it (blue1.jpg). Just to keep up with the copyright of the picture (creative commons), it's from "m-a-e" in flickr. I searched for blue lol
edit: I no longer need to think whether I need a yellow filter ;) the effect here though is probably one from a very strong yellow filter and not #12.