Ubuntu Forums Archive Viewer

Human verification questions

Archived thread 2049507 from Forum Council Agenda Items. Markdown source: Forum_Council_Agenda_Items/thread_2049507_Human_verification_questions.md

Original URL About this archive
#1

http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=2031174

Is it working?

Do we need more in the bank?

#2

It seems to be working, but for how long. Maybe we should have enough questions, so that they could be rotated at unspecific intervals.

#3

I'm monitoring daily registrations, and they are creeping up gradually:

http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=2031174

Figures for both 27th and 28th Aug are over 400, which is worrying, but are slightly inflated by registrations from the @new-purse.com email domain, which continued even after adding the domain to the email domain ban list. I think we are seeing the bilberry and lingonberry not talking to each other phenomenon with email banning as well - which is infuriating.

I have a few spare questions in reserve but, yes, I agree we need to decide whether to rotate them on a regular basis or wait until registration numbers are high again before changing them.

About rotating questions. I have no direct evidence for this, just a sensible inference from the fact that bots were getting past our old HV questions, but if bots or spam herders really are harvesting questions and pre-programming bots with Qs and As, then rotation of questions is unlikely to work. We would need an inexhaustible supply of new questions, which ain't going to be easy. :(